A pirate walked into a bar
spyglass, leather armor, 6 spears
silver tankard, silver locket, 5 lbs of pepper in wax paper, trio of silver shoe buckles, gold ring, silver hat pin, 5 large silver buttons,
Scrimshaw octopus with a dozen gold rings. 6 pearls (75gp each). Scrimshaw blade (125gp), 8 silver ingots (20gp each). Hammerhead shark skull (250gp). Ivory walrus tusk set with gold (map of the shackles) 400gp, Harp from jaw of Orca set with pearls (500gp).
Ring of swimming + 5 to swim
Potion of water breathing
Potion of cure moderate wounds.
Magic anchor feather token
Wand of Mirror Image (23 charges).
Wand of summon nature's ally 2 (12 charges).
Huge magic whale skull: scrolls of alter self, black tentacles, blur, color spray, daylight, enlarge person, hypnotism, slow, touch of idiocy, and vampiric touch.
Vindictive harpoon, + 1 returning harpoon, made from the tusk of a narwhal (no penalties underwater).
Single lesser bracelet of archery (needs pair to work)